Understanding Behaviors: When is it Normal vs. Symptomatic?

This is the first of a special series of blogs about general health by CareTec! There’s plenty of TEC content, this is pure CARE content – ENJOY!

Human behavior is diverse, and many actions that might seem concerning in one context can be entirely normal or harmless in another. It's important to recognize that:

1. Cultural Norms & Personal Eccentricities

   What’s considered unusual or “odd” behavior in one culture or society might be completely normal elsewhere. For instance, some people are naturally more introverted, obsessive about details, or prone to creative bursts without it indicating a mental health issue.

   Example: Over-explaining or perfectionism can simply be part of someone’s personality, particularly in high-achievers or those with strong attention to detail. Unless it interferes with their daily life or happiness, it may not be a cause for concern.

2. Context Matters

   Behaviors like excessive sleep, overeating, or erratic spending could be responses to temporary stress or life changes, not necessarily a sign of a mental health condition.

   Example: Eating junk food or living paycheck to paycheck during times of financial stress or emotional turbulence doesn’t automatically indicate depression or anxiety. It may just be a temporary phase of life.

3. Eccentricity vs. Dysfunction

   Some people lead perfectly functional and happy lives with habits that others might find unconventional. Eccentricity is not the same as illness; many great innovators, artists, and thinkers exhibit behaviors that could be seen as “out of the ordinary” but are integral to their genius and creativity.

   Example: Someone with compulsive creative periods or an obsession with a particular hobby may simply be passionate or deeply engaged, not exhibiting signs of mania or obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

Labels: The Power and Problem of Diagnosis

Mental health diagnoses are, at their core, medical opinions—often based on scientific evidence, but still human interpretations of a person’s experiences. While these labels can offer clarity, they also come with some potential drawbacks:

1. Mental Illness as a Medical Opinion

   Terms like “Addiction,” “anxiety,” “depression,” “bipolar disorder,” and “ADHD” are labels created by medical professionals to group similar patterns of thought, behaviour, or emotion. These labels help provide treatment pathways and make sense of what someone is going through, but they aren’t always perfect or universally applicable.

   Example: Someone diagnosed with anxiety might find it helpful to understand why they feel the way they do, but another person with similar symptoms might not find the label helpful and may resist being defined by it.

2. The Risk of Over-Diagnosis

   In some wealthy, well-resourced societies, there can be a tendency to over-diagnose certain behaviors, giving people a medical explanation for what might simply be normal emotional fluctuations or life challenges. Over-diagnosis can lead to over-reliance on medication or a tendency to view oneself as “broken” when the person is just going through a tough time.

   Example: In countries with more access to mental health resources, it's easier for a person who is simply stressed to be diagnosed with anxiety, which may encourage them to cling to that label as a defining trait instead of addressing the root causes of their stress.

3. Self-Identification with Labels

   Once a person receives a diagnosis, there’s a risk of them overly identifying with it. This can create a sense of permanence around their condition, making them believe that they are bound by it rather than capable of change or growth. While some diagnoses can help with understanding oneself better, they shouldn’t limit a person’s sense of agency or ability to improve their well-being.

   Example: A person diagnosed with ADHD might start attributing every challenge they face to that diagnosis, using it as a reason not to try new strategies or push beyond certain perceived limitations. This can be limiting to their potential.

4. Social and Political Implications of Labels

   In socialist or welfare-based societies, people might have easier access to mental health services, but the societal push towards diagnosing and treating every emotional issue can sometimes create a culture of over-pathologizing normal human struggles. People might begin to see themselves as mentally ill when they are simply dealing with typical life difficulties.

   Example: A person living paycheck to paycheck might start viewing their financial stress as a symptom of anxiety or depression, rather than recognizing it as a normal reaction to economic strain and working to build more financial stability over time.

Balancing Diagnosis with Individual Freedom

While it’s important to acknowledge when mental health conditions are present and to seek appropriate support, we must also recognize the individual’s right to navigate their life with a sense of autonomy. Labels can sometimes become restrictive, framing a person’s entire identity around their diagnosis. Instead, we should aim to:

• Focus on Well-being, Not Just Labels

  Support should focus on helping individuals lead fulfilling, happy lives, whether that involves managing a diagnosed condition or simply learning better coping strategies for life’s challenges.

• Avoid Pathologizing Every Difference

  It’s essential to allow room for personal quirks, eccentricities, and emotional diversity without jumping to conclusions about mental illness. Some people thrive with unconventional habits that aren’t indicative of deeper issues.

• Empowerment Over Diagnosis

  Encourage people to view their mental health journey as a process of growth and self-understanding, rather than a fixed diagnosis. Empowerment comes from recognizing one's capacity to improve, heal, and adapt, rather than being confined by a label.

Conclusion: A Compassionate Approach

In summary, while recognizing signs of mental illness is important, it’s equally critical to avoid pathologizing every behavior or labeling eccentricities as disorders. Mental health diagnoses, though useful, are not the ultimate truth of a person’s identity or potential. They are tools for understanding, not limits on personal growth or happiness. A balanced approach allows for both empathy and empowerment, encouraging people to seek help when needed while also acknowledging that everyone has their own unique journey.

Disclaimer: The information provided in this blog is for general informational purposes only and is not intended as professional medical advice, diagnosis, or treatment. I am not a licensed healthcare professional, and the views expressed are my personal opinions. Always consult a qualified medical professional or healthcare provider with any questions or concerns regarding your health or medical conditions.

Read more about the author here.